Your Painting (and Mine!) Fails Because of THIS
Avoid This Beginner Painting Mistake

Since the mid-1800s, numerous artists (and beginner painting students) have stressed color over other elements in painting. They mistake color choice as the root of all success or failure in painting. And, they cite the Impressionists as examples.
However Claude Monet, for instance, explored how to paint light and its effects on the colorful scenes he saw in his mind’s eye. Although many think of Monet as a painter of colors, he is perhaps more accurately described as the original “painter of light.”
Paintings fail or succeed most often because of how accurate the color values are in the work, rather than because of poor color choices or color mixing. The viewer “reads” a painting through its values. And a composition relies on how light and dark values are arranged. The problem is novice painting artists often see a color’s hue and chroma instead of its value.
How to Paint Like a Pro Instead
Painting a grisaille (a composition in shades of gray) before applying colors can help match the correct values in a scene to a desired hue in the proper value. A few exercises juxtaposing values on a grayscale with various local colors also help in training our eyes.
“The best way to understand color is working with it,” says Laura Antonow, who teaches a class on color theory in the art department at The University of Mississippi. “Learning how to mix paint, matching paints or fabrics, looking at colors in daylight and then under artificial light — all of these can help develop your color sensitivity.”

Antonow also stresses beginner painters (and veterans, for that matter) should be vigilant about avoiding one painting art misconception: that color exists in a vacuum.
“When considering a certain color, people forget to take into [account] the surrounding colors, the lighting conditions, and even the cultural context, all of which are extremely important to the way a color appears,” she says.
Beyond encouraging trial-and-error color experimentation, Antonow also suggests reading about color theory from authors such as Josef Albers, Albert H. Munsell, Johannes Itten, and Johann Wolfgang von Goethe. Additionally, she recommends paying close attention to the work of artists known for their dynamic use of color, such as Wassily Kandinsky and Mark Rothko.
Hone In on Color
Discover more ways to hone your color sensibilities with the Acrylic Color Essentials bundle. With the exercises in this collection, you can combine the brilliant colors and buttery application of the acrylics you love with value and color savviness. Create color wheels and mix tints, tones, shades and neutrals.
What’s more, learn how to layer color, explore value in-depth, figure out what to do when color “accidents” arise and see how to let your own personal color instincts lead the way. Below is a preview of art you can make with this colorful bundle. Enjoy!

Artists Network Membership - 1 Year
Breakthrough Paint Along: Where Mixed Media Combine Together
Paint Along 127: Paint the Motion of the Sea
Breakthrough Paint Along: The Big Value of Miniature Landscapes
Portrait Painting: Rembrandt's Techniques Video Download
Figure Drawing Tips with Brent Eviston Video Download
Southwest Art August/September 2025 Digital Edition
Artists Magazine July/August 2025 Digital Edition
Pastel Journal Summer 2025 Digital Edition
Artists Magazine March/April 2025 Digital Edition
Artists Magazine January/February 2025 Digital Edition
Best of Watercolor: Winners of the Splash 26 Competition Print Edition
Southwest Art June/July 2025 Print Edition
Artists Magazine May/June 2025 Print Edition
Southwest Art 2021 Digital Collection × 1
Watercolor Artist 2020 Digital Collection × 1
Watercolor Artist 2019 Annual Digital Collection × 1
Watercolor Mega Magazine Collection × 1
Pastel for Beginners Workshop
Composition & Design for Landscape Painting Video Workbook
Drawing Mastery: Shading Course
Alla Prima Bootcamp: 4 Weeks to Confident Painting Course
Eight Greats: The Pastel Journal's 10th Anniversary Artist Interview Series Digital Download
Secrets of Hyperrealist Watercolor Course
Acrylic Artist Summer 2017 Digital Edition
Exploring Acrylic: Abstract Art in Action Video Download
WetCanvas Live! Paint Stunning Landscapes from Photos: Lesson 23 & 24 Video Download
WetCanvas Live! Paint Stunning Landscapes from Photos: Lesson 9 & 10 Video Download
The Whimsical Face with Jane Davenport Video Download
Mixed-Media Faces Made Easy Video Download
What It Takes to Teach Video Download
On the hunt for found objects: How to Create New and Eclectic Molds Video Download
Urban Sketching: Drawing People in Places Video Workbook
Graffiti Grunge Art by Jodi Ohl Video Workbook
Portraits: From Good to Great Video Download
Low-Tech Metal Apps: Wire, Foil, Mesh, & Screen Video Download
Paint Along 126: Simplify Your Landscapes with a Limited Palette
Experimental Pastel Techniques with Dawn Emerson Video Download
Painting Patterned Trees Video Download
Paint Along 125: Paint the Charming Towns of Italy
Essentials of Painting Still Lifes
7 Days to a Steady Journal Practice Video Download
Really good advice! This is one of the first things I teach my students. Value is completely different than hue!
Hi MJD,
You make an interesting pint about color perception. Email me at [email protected] if you would like to discuss guest blogging about the topic. Would look forward to that. All best,
Courtney Jordan
“Color as value” is an outdated perceptual way of thinking.
If you start with value based thinking you will never develop your eye to see in color. Monet discovered this through his objective study of color relationships in nature. There is color theory and there is color understanding. Two very different things.
I wrote an article on color perception to try to explain the difference.
Here is the link – if am able to give one.
http://www.swintonsart.com/blog-articles/item/color-perception
Applying a composition in Grisaille (shades of grey), seems an ideal solution, to complete a picture, I shall try this, on some future art work.
Loved your article on Why Paintings Fail or Succeed. So true about values of color, and how they affect one another. Very good idea to do value sketches….and I loved your comparison to Rothko and Kandinsky……what powerful use of color values by these two artists.
Couldn’t agree more about the importance of value. Some artists that suffer from colour deficiencies can create successful works of art through the clever use of value.